• Custom Writing Services
  • How to Write a Research Paper
  • Research Paper Topics
  • Research Paper Examples
  • Order

Communication

iResearchNet

Custom Writing Services

Custom Writing Services
Communication » Media » Separation of News and Comments

Separation of News and Comments




News and comment cannot coexist independently in a social system. Factual news and comment become twisted together like two strands of a rope. What is news? What is commentary? When we think of news, we often think of facts that refer to specific objects or events in the world. By contrast, commentary usually refers to a larger context. Commentary frames news. News and commentary are constructed of words, pictures, sounds, or other symbols of social meaning, but the communicator’s intent is different in each case. News reports aim to reconstruct events, to create pictures in the minds of audiences. Commentary aims to shape how audiences construct these events. Commentary has intent. While news media usually are careful to separate news from commentary, audiences naturally blend them together. We can obtain a picture of events from news stories alone, as all news stories contain some evaluative descriptions beyond the facts, and one can learn events from commentaries alone, and still will learn some facts.

The separation of news from comment can be studied in all communication systems – in some there is more separation at times than in others, more in some periods of history, less in others (societies under stress) – but news and comment cannot be easily separated and must be evaluated in terms of how they interact within a particular social system. Even if media strictly separate news from editorials and columns, audiences necessarily put the two together as part of the construction of social reality.




One can make an analogy with agenda-setting theory. Agenda setting, level 1, proposes that the connection between media and audiences at the level of news topics is close. Agenda setting, level 2, argues that the connection between the details in news stories and audience attention is likewise close. Within agenda-setting theory one can argue that news stories contain a heavy focus on facts with some details about events, while news commentary focuses on interpretive detail linked with the same facts. McCombs (2004) has called major news event topics “objects” and details about events “attributes.” In this sense, news stories could be described as objects-over-attributes messages, while commentary can be visualized as attributes-over-objects messages. No message is purely news and no message is purely commentary. There is always a mixture.

Attributes contextualize objects, as the comments of editorial writers, columnists, letters to the editor, photographs, and audio and video contextualize the facts of news events on the front page. If we lived in the controlled environments in which behavioral psychologist B. F. Skinner limited behavior and provided rewards for correct behavior, we might expect the relationships between news (objects) and comment (attributes), demonstrated by correlations between news and audiences, to be close to 1.00. That is, audiences given proper rewards for attending to messages would reflect  messages in exactly the proportions in which they are presented, in terms of objects and attributes, and audiences therefore would be quite able to keep separate in their heads information learned from news and that learned from commentary. Of course, no one does that, even if the media carefully separate news and commentary.

Professional journalists constantly wrestle with balancing fact and comment statements. Journalists construct their social roles relative to the way they gather, organize, and present messages, nearly always with reference to some larger professional duty, such as fairness or objectivity. Clarity in dividing news and comment is often determined by culture. France’s Le Monde and Germany’s Der Spiegel contextualize news. In Britain, the Daily Telegraph and the Guardian are newspapers to which audiences turn for a dependable selection and presentation of news and commentary consistent with their own views. The separation of news and commentary cannot really be addressed without reference to political and cultural systems. The Chinese government tolerates a wide range of news, and even some comment, about purely economic issues, but requires political news to exist within a particular, tightly controlled range. US journalists pride themselves on their objectivity about news, defined as presenting political messages that provide equal, or at least fair, attention to all aspects of political issues, while directing commentary to editorial pages or personal columns. The free market system exerts influence. Many countries, from Russia to Syria to China, have government-controlled television networks. Britain’s BBC is government-funded, but editorially independent. Al Jazeera represents still another model that is consistently non-objective, while being ostensibly independent of government authority. In fact, all systems find a natural balance between news and comment, however defined for a given national system and culture.

Political leaders, journalists, social scientists, and others are interested in media systems that help citizens function responsibly. There are many ways to examine the performance of information systems in presenting news and comment. There are basically two empirical measures to examine the separation of news and commentary. The first looks at the use of language in the news. What topics are covered? The second compares the valence of items in the news or commentary. To this latter approach belong “synchronization studies.” They assess the degree to which news and commentary are separated in a news system or in individual news outlets. By means of content analyses one can compare how the valence of the news items correlates with the valence of commentaries on the same issue. One study found that newspapers in the United States reported the number of participants in anti-war demonstrations that were consistent with the newspapers’ position on the Vietnam War, as expressed in their editorials and opinion columns. Similar results were found for German reports about the Berlin conflict in the 1970s (Schönbach 1977) and several other political issues (Kepplinger et al. 1991; Hagen 1992).

The balance between news and commentary varies from country to country, culture to culture. Agenda-setting studies in Germany, Britain, Taiwan, Korea, Japan, Australia, and various countries in Africa and South America suggest audiences everywhere are likely to reflect attention to news and commentary in predictable patterns. If we used the same heuristic as Sir Isaac Newton – the attraction of forces, not objects – we might conclude that while news and comment may appear adverse to each other within any particular national or cultural setting, audiences meld news and comment into a social construction that fits their own lives, reflecting, perhaps, a law of social gravity that we have not yet discovered.

References:

  1. Hagen, L. (1992). Die opportunen Zeugen: Konstruktionsmechanismen von Bias in der Zeitungsberichterstattung über die Volkszählungsdiskussion [The opportune witnesses: Mechanisms of the construction of bias in news on the micro census]. Publizistik, 37, 444–460.
  2. Kepplinger, H. M., Brosius, H.-B., & Staab, J. F. (1991). Instrumental actualization: A theory of mediated conflicts. European Journal of Communication, 6, 263–290.
  3. Mann, L. (1974). Counting the crowd: Effects of editorial policy on estimates. Journalism Quarterly, 55, 278–285.
  4. McCombs, M. (2004). Setting the agenda: The mass media and public opinion. Cambridge: Polity.
  5. Schönbach, K. (1977). Trennung von Nachricht und Meinung: Empirische Untersuchung eines journalistischen Qualitätskriteriums [Separation of facts and opinion: An empirical study of a criterion of journalistic quality]. Freiburg and Munich: Karl Alber.




Communication Research

Communication Research

  • Media
    • Media Economics
    • Media Effects
    • Media History
    • Media Production and Content
    • Media Systems
    • Media and Perceptions of Reality
    • Excitation Transfer Theory
    • Effects Of Exemplification And Exemplars
    • Economics of Advertising
    • Antitrust Regulation
    • Audience Commodity
    • Brands
    • Circulation
    • Commercialization of the Media
    • Competition in Media Systems
    • Concentration in Media Systems
    • Consolidation of Media Markets
    • Consumers in Media Markets
    • Cost and Revenue Structures in the Media
    • Cross-Media Marketing
    • Distribution
    • Diversification of Media Markets
    • Economies of Scale in Media Markets
    • Globalization of the Media
    • Labor in the Media
    • Labor Unions in the Media
    • Markets of the Media
    • Media Conglomerates
    • Media Management
    • Media Marketing
    • Mergers
    • Ownership in the Media
    • Piracy
    • Political Economy of the Media
    • Privatization of the Media
    • Forms of Media Corporations
    • Public Goods
    • Agenda-Setting Effects
    • Appraisal Theory
    • Media Effects on Attitudes, Values, and Beliefs
    • Cognitive Availability
    • Albert Bandura
    • Catharsis Theory
    • Steven H. Chaffee
    • Credibility Effects
    • Cumulative Media Effects
    • Desensitization
    • Diffusion of Information and Innovation
    • Emotional Arousal Theory
    • Media Effects on Emotions
    • Effects of Entertainment
    • Fear Induction through Media Content
    • Leon Festinger
    • Framing Effects
    • Frustration Aggression Theory
    • George Gerbner
    • Carl I. Hovland
    • Intercultural Media Effects
    • Elihu Katz
    • Knowledge Gap Effects
    • Latitude of Acceptance
    • Linear and Nonlinear Models of Causal Analysis
    • Mainstreaming
    • Media Effects: Direct and Indirect Effects
    • Media Effects Duration
    • History of Media Effects
    • Media Effects Models: Elaborated Models
    • Strength of Media Effects
    • Media System Dependency Theory
    • Mediating Factors
    • Mediatization of Society
    • Structure of Message Effect
    • Elisabeth Noelle-Neumann
    • Effects of Nonverbal Signals
    • Observational Learning
    • Opinion Leader
    • Order of Presentation
    • Persuasion
    • Physical Effects of Media Content
    • Priming Theory
    • Media Effects on Public Opinion
    • Reciprocal Effects
    • Schemas and Media Effects
    • Effects of Sex and Pornography as Media Content
    • Sleeper Effect
    • Media Effects on Social Behavior
    • Media Effects on Social Capital
    • Social Judgment Theory
    • Trap Effect
    • Two-Step Flow of Communication
    • Secondary Victimization
    • Effects of Violence as Media Content
    • Academy Awards
    • History of Advertising
    • BBC
    • Cable Television
    • History of Censorship
    • History of Cinematography
    • History of Citizen Journalism
    • Civil Rights Movement and the Media
    • Coffee Houses as Public Sphere
    • Effects of Violence as Media Content
    • Academy Awards
    • Collective Memory and the Media
    • History of Digital Media
    • History of Documentary Film
    • History of Elections and Media
    • Electronic Mail
    • Federal Communications Commission (FCC)
    • Fleet Street
    • Fourth Estate
    • Graffiti
    • Historic Key Events and the Media
    • Illustrated Newspapers
    • Literary Journalism
    • History of Magazine
    • Music Videos
    • Nineteenth-Century New Journalism
    • History of News Agencies
    • History of News Magazine
    • Newscast
    • 24-Hour Newscast
    • Antecedents of Newspaper
    • History of Newspaper
    • Paperback Fiction
    • Penny Press
    • History of Postal Service
    • History of Printing
    • Newsreel
    • Freedom of Communication
    • Propaganda in World War II
    • History of Public Broadcasting
    • Radical Media
    • Radio Networks
    • Radio: Social History
    • Radio Technology
    • Satellite Television
    • History of Sports and the Media
    • History of Telegraph
    • Television Networks
    • Television: Social History
    • Television Technology
    • Underground Press
    • History of Violence and the Media
    • Virtual Reality
    • Watergate Scandal
    • Women’s Movement and the Media
    • Accountability of the Media
    • Accountability of the News
    • Accuracy
    • Balance
    • Bias in the News
    • Commentary
    • Commercialization: Impact on Media Content
    • Conflict as Media Content
    • Consonance of Media Content
    • Construction of Reality through the News
    • Credibility of Content
    • Crime Reporting
    • Editorial
    • Endorsement
    • Ethics of Media Content
    • Fairness Doctrine
    • Fictional Media Content
    • Framing of the News
    • Infotainment
    • Instrumental Actualization
    • Internet
    • Internet News
    • Local News
    • Magazine
    • Media Performance
    • Morality and Taste in Media Content
    • Narrative News Story
    • Negativity
    • Neutrality
    • News
    • News Factors
    • News Production and Technology
    • News Values
    • Newspaper
    • Objectivity in Reporting
    • Plurality
    • Quality of the News
    • Quality Press
    • Radio
    • Radio News
    • Reality and Media Reality
    • Scandalization in the News
    • Sensationalism
    • Separation of News and Comments
    • Soap Operas
    • Soft News
    • Sound Bites
    • Stereotypes
    • Synchronization of the News
    • Tabloid Press
    • Tabloidization
    • Television
    • News
    • Truth and Media Content
    • Violence as Media Content
    • Africa: Media Systems
    • Austria: Media System
    • Balkan States: Media Systems
    • Baltic States: Media Systems
    • Argentina: Media System
    • Bolivia: Media System
    • Brazil: Media System
    • Canada: Media System
    • Caribbean States: Media Systems
    • Central America: Media Systems
    • Chile: Media System
    • China: Media System
    • Colombia: Media System
    • Convergence of Media Systems
    • Cuba: Media System
    • Czech Republic: Media System
    • Egypt: Media System
    • France: Media System
    • Germany: Media System
    • Gulf States: Media Systems
    • India: Media System
    • Iran: Media System
    • Israel: Media System
    • Italy: Media System
    • Japan: Media System
    • Malaysia: Media System
    • Mexico: Media System
    • Netherlands: Media System
    • North Africa: Media Systems
    • Poland: Media System
    • Portugal: Media System
    • Public Broadcasting Systems
    • Russia: Media System
    • Scandinavian States: Media Systems
    • Singapore: Media System
    • South Africa: Media System
    • South Korea: Media System
    • Spain: Media System
    • Switzerland: Media System
    • United Kingdom: Media System
    • United States of America: Media System
    • West Asia: Media Systems
    • Behavioral Norms: Perception through the Media
    • Body Images in the Media
    • Computer Games and Reality Perception
    • Cultivation Effects
    • Disowning Projection
    • Entertainment Content and Reality Perception
    • Extra-Media Data
    • False Consensus
    • False Uniqueness
    • Media Campaigns And Perceptions Of Reality
    • Media Content and Social Networks
    • Media Messages and Family Communication
    • Media and Perceptions of Reality
    • Perceived Realism as a Decision Process
    • Perceived Reality as a Communication Process
    • Perceived Reality: Meta-Analyses
    • Perceived Reality as a Social Process
    • Pluralistic Ignorance
    • Pluralistic Ignorance and Ideological Biases
    • Social Perception
    • Social Perception: Impersonal Impact
    • Social Perception: Unrealistic Optimism
    • Socialization by the Media
    • Spiral of Silence
    • Stereotyping and the Media
    • Third-Person Effects
    • Video Malaise

Custom Writing Services

Custom Writing Services